CCRAP and what to do about it.

Posted in Land Contamination / Scotland with tags , , , on August 20, 2011 by ewanwmcdonald

July in Glasgow saw much civic triumphalism as a new motorway route was opened, the M74 extension . The noise mediation works are impressive, perhaps a modicum of a concession to environmentalists opposing road building in the city. It is a shame though that such engineering innovation could not be directed towards sustainable transport infrastructure in Scotland.

Campaigns challenging Glasgow’s obsession with major cemented arterioles have been prominent in the media and  important in building green-left alliances in the city. The Pollok Free State, a group opposed to motorway construction in vast green space of Pollok Park, was one such infamous and long-standing campaign in the 1990’s http://www.giventothepeople.org/. During this time I remember being on the other side of the fence, working on an environmental impact assessment for Strathclyde Regional Council on  the re-alignment of the A77, which would actually be completed as a motorway. I recall incidents surrounding the protests, a Conservative MP attacking the Pollok Park defenders. Although I also remember this time as when Celtic Football Club were contemplating relocating to Cambuslang and the M74 extension was first mooted.

The new motorway was built but Celtic abandoned plans for a South-East home on the outer reaches of Glasgow partly as a result of a community group unearthing information on heavily contaminated land. Cambuslang, Carmyle and Rutherglen Against Pollution, campaigning with the wonderful acronym CCRAP, undertook research on the extent of chromium waste in Rutherglen and beyond. A former member of the group comments in the Urban Glasgow blog

‘By the end of our research we listed 65 sites throughout the areas from Cambuslang to Dumbarton. 
There was a study by Dames and Moore which cost the Council over £250,000 and there were specific recommendations on how to deal with the toxic waste. At the Glencairn Football site, one of the most contaminated, there was to be a a bubble environment where workers were to work in it, with hazard suits and respiratory equipment. Clean air would be controlled and no air was to escape from the bubble. 
I am not kidding this was like out of a science fiction book! But when you go down there now, nothing has been done to protect the workers, people living there and the cars passing by going into Glasgow. 
This whole M74 project has not stuck to the Dames and Moore report at all. That is where all your taxpayers money goes, on reports that never see the light of day and gather dust up at the Environmental Health Department and the Mitchell Library. ‘

The principal concern was with the former White Chemical works, operating up to 1967 and manufacturing 70% of the U.K.s chromate products. This site was cordoned off in 1992 and a public health campaign erupted over suspected linked  cases of  leukaemia and  kidney tumours in the area.  There is evidence of carcinogenic effects from chromium particularly amongst chromate workers. However, academic and government research revealed no clustering in South East Glasgow and so the issue subsided in the Scottish media. More can be written on this environmental justice struggle as some belated success has been achieved with re-mediation of contaminated land recently proceeding in Rutherglen and Cambuslang (see below).

http://www.rutherglenreformer.co.uk/rutherglen-news/rutherglen-local-news/2010/06/09/rutherglen-and-cambuslang-set-to-benefit-from-regeneration-programmes-63227-26614359/

Petrochemical plant closure in China following large protest

Posted in Pollution / International on August 15, 2011 by ewanwmcdonald

I spotted this bit of news in the Guardian today. I have now discovered the hard copy paper version is only really a ‘guide’  to the web portal! (just a small paragraph in the broadsheet)

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/aug/14/china-petrochemical-plant-shutdown-protest?INTCMP=SRCH

Estimates of 12,000 to 70,000 protesters, despite the best efforts of the Chinese government to thwart political organising on social networks. Interesting to note wider issue of political corruption also attached to the environmental protest.

Further news on http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/08/14/us-china-protests-idUSTRE77D0EK20110814

Environmental Justice : Global and Local

Posted in Introducing Steeltoun with tags , , , on August 14, 2011 by ewanwmcdonald

We should all be entitled to live, work and play in healthy and safe environments but more often than not it is the poor and most vulnerable who are denied this basic human right. Environmental injustice is common place and a global phenomenon.

Recently shown in a U.N. report, the gargantuan oil company Shell has caused untold damage to the health of Ogoni communities in the Niger Delta whilst the firm was also charged with collusion in the execution of nine local human rights activists. A British oil trader Trafigura, was convicted last year of criminal charges following the  dumping of toxic waste in the Ivory Coast and consequent ill health to 30,000 people. The Indian Bhopal disaster in 1984 further exemplifies corporate disdain for the lives and health of local vulnerable populations. On a wider scale is the obsequious injustice of the world’s poorest disproportionally suffering from the effects of climate change, whilst those responsible, the global rich, conveniently spurn actions on redress and environmental regulation

 Such a state of affairs in the global South is egregious and shocking, however it  is often easier to identify with the concept of environmental justice at a local level. Are our own environments safe and healthy? Such as where we live, or work? What about where our family members are? at school? at a day centre? in a residential care facility? Clearly there is regulatory framework in Scotland aiming to ensure health and safety for all homes and workplaces; agencies such as Health Protection Scotland and the Scottish Environmental Protection Authority. However cracks can appear in the regulatory regime where    communities and workers challenge ‘expert’ reports or opinion, directing their own energies into claiming the right for a local healthy environment. This is not  always a struggle against large polluting private corporations but also challenging national and local authorities to reverse policies and actions which are equally deleterious to human health.

For Scotland many issues arise, we have a particular toxic legacy of waste deposits from heavy industrial manufacturing and many areas of contaminated land in the central belt. The blog title, steeltoun, reflects such a characteristic of our urban post-industrial landscape. A further Scottish dimension is that state-owned post-war housing has now reached its use by date and renovation and relocation bring potentially new health and safety problems for social housing tenants. Scotland is also not immune from  ‘austerity’ rationalisation of the public sector where withdrawal of key services can detrimentally affect the health of the most vulnerable. The processing of waste and proposals for biomass incineration plants in close proximity to deprived areas in Scotland is also another key matter for concern. Of course this list of issues is by no means exhaustive.

I hope this blog will provide some insight on environmental justice in Scotland and beyond. I will be including features of campaigns here and further afield, commentary on newspaper articles or academic papers and also summaries of my own research on reproductive health and  epidemiology.

Links:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/global-development/2011/aug/09/niger-delta-shell-oil-spills?INTCMP=SRCH

http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2011/aug/04/niger-delta-oil-spill-clean-up-un?INTCMP=SRCH

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/sep/16/trafigura-oil-pollution-fortune-tragedy?INTCMP=SRCH

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/jul/23/trafigura-dutch-fine-waste-export?INTCMP=SRCH